And at last, here we are at the start of spring training. This offseason was anything but an off season for big league managers and front offices. The looming questions that needed answers such as who to sign, how much to pay them, how long to sign them for, who’s worth giving up a first round draft pick, and the list of questions goes on. With Ian Desmond possibly going to the Rockies to fill in for Jose Reyes while he is suspended and Dexter Fowler resigning with the Chicago Cubs, the list of “talent” still out there is not all that good. It’s no big surprise teams are trading for prospects instead of inking deals with the free agents still out there. Last week the Brewers continued their rebuilding by trading Khris Davis to the Oakland A’s for prospects Bubba Derby (RHP) and Jacob Nottingham (C). Why not go to the free agent pool and sign a veteran or two? In all honesty, would it really hurt a team like the Brewers, Reds, Phillies, or Orioles to sign some of these guys?
The answer is yes it would and heres why. Owners are not willing to give up a first round draft pick unless it comes with a huge discount. These teams are all loading up on prospects that they want to coach and get playing time to dial in their skill set. If you deviate from that plan it will stunt the growth of these young players. The unsigned free agents out there remain unsigned for a reason, they are just not that good. Baseball is a young mans game and just because the players are known names, doesn’t mean owners and managers want them on their rosters. Their wins above replacement (WAR), although they might look good on paper for a team that is in a rebuilding phase, are not the way to go. If you take a team the like the Phillies, that has almost nothing but young players that have yet to prove them self on a big league level, the WAR for a veteran is going to be skewed. Take those same players WAR on the Toronto Blue Jays or the New York Mets and you will find different results. MLB is all about PECOTA these days, but it too has yet to prove anything since it’s seldom correct. In fact, former big leaguer and MLB Analyst, Harold Reynolds, thinks baseball should get rid of PECOTA all together. You have to stick to your plan of rebuilding, even if it means going into a season your team is looking at 60-65 wins. Here’s a full list of players that remain on the unsigned.
With that being said, this does not mean that these players will remain unsigned. Keep in mind that spring training injuries will open the door for players to come prove themselves to a club. There will also be injuries during the season or players that just don’t cut it on the big league level. Last year, Adam Wainwright went down early on for the Cardinals so they had to rely heavily on their pipeline of talent. If that happens to a club this year they could look to a pitcher like Tim Lincecum or Jeremy Guthrie to eat innings and hopefully contribute in the rotation. Looking at the list of players, there are guys that could step into a role on a team at almost every position. One of the issues teams are facing is how much these players are wanting to be paid. After having a career year in 2015, Fowler turned down a qualifying offer from the Cubs for $15.8 million to test the market. He eventually resigned with them for $13 million and other options not yet released to the press. Unfortunately MLB did this to themselves by paying these players ridiculous contracts. They let super agents like Scott Boras inflate these players heads and strong arm teams into paying their ungodly contracts. Just wait until Bryce Harper comes up for contact in a couple years. The discussions of him being the first player in MLB history to be paid over $500 million dollars have already started. Baseball needs to remember this game was built around the fans loyalty not the players salaries. When ticket prices soar and beers cost $30 a pop, attendance will surely drop.